Dear Jay and Kyle, Liz and I observed your marketing style and can tell that you have given much thought and effort to developing it into the viable tool it is today. Your hard work and diligence win the day in the long run. We hope we have contributed to your effectiveness by providing backup and prompt decisions when needed. We always felt we were part of a team working toward a common goal. We found it easy to communicate with you both and we hope your impression of us is positive also. Results are the measuring gauge for any task and you...

Liz & Nick P.

Jay and Kyle Mitchell were excellent agents to deal with. They were thorough, knowledgeable, approachable, professional, trustworthy, and personable. They went above and beyond the call of duty, holding multiple Open Houses, keeping me informed, dealing with multiple offers, etc. I have no hesitation in recommending Jay and Kyle to anyone and everyone who is looking for a real estate agent.

Marlene B.

Agents were recommended by a close friend. I was extremely pleased with every aspect of the sale and purchase of my new home. They were the best I have ever experienced. I would recommend them to anyone buying or selling.

Sue Marley

This was a great experience and the smoothest home purchase we have ever had! Jay and the mortgage and closing teams worked extremely well together to make sure everything was handled. We walked into the office and met Jay and were very impressed with his knowledge of the local market. We very quickly built trust in this team. Jay and Kyle are true professionals who took really good care of us every step of the way. I highly recommend them to anyone moving to the area or looking to upgrade. They know all the options and pros and cons associa...

John H.

Jay and Kyle Mitchell were great to work with. They both were so flexible, patient, and worked well with everyone involved. They continually kept us in the loop of things, such as when open houses and private showings were happening and updates after each. The whole process, from start to finish, went smoothly and it was due to their knowledge and expertise. We would definitely hire Jay and Kyle Mitchell for any future real estate purchase or sale!

Claudia G.

We would like to thank you for all the work you put forth in selling our Harbor Towers unit on beautiful Siesta Key. From the moment we chose you to be our listing agent, we benefitted from your professional expertise and knowledgeable experience in the Sarasota Real Estate market. Your thoughtful suggestions to make our property more appealing and your guidance in, appropriate pricing helped to sell our unit. Thanks also for the great communication throughout this process, including statistics on buyer traffic, showings appointments, intern...

Jean & Steve G.

The broker was not the important part of our decision. Jay and Kyle were our agents when we bought the house in 2005. Great to work with from 2005 to 2020! During a pandemic, we all did the best we could Jay and Kyle have helped us for the last 15 years. From buying our investment property to providing comps through the years.They helped us get our house under contract within days. They suggested that we have our own home inspection, so we would know exactly what needed to be fixed or improved. They kept us calm throughout the closing proces...

Lisa R.

I have worked with several Realtors® and I can say that Jay and Kyle Mitchell are the most knowledgeable and professional. They were always available by phone or email. Coordinating the sale and purchase of properties is nerve-wracking. They set up multiple viewings for my home, made a beautiful picture, moreover they helped me to find a great contractor to fix the problems in my house. It was really helpful. Kyle and Jay genuinely love what they do, and this is reflected not only in their communications but also exhibited in their efforts. ...


J and K ran a very aggressive campaign of home showings - they also used friends to host extra open houses. Prev broker had one open house in six months, but no one came. We had a home larger than many were looking for, but the Mitchells found us a buyer looking for space and we had a very smooth selling process. Dey da best! While our buyer didn't come thru Siesta Key, we in Venice think (rightly or wrongly) that the buyers with money looking for a classy place to live, land in Sarasota. Once here they may discover Venice, which most have l...

Jim C.

Jay was very proactive in emailing me listings he thought met our criteria to help us narrow our search. That was very helpful since I planned only a few days in FL to find a condo. I like that he showed me some lower-quality units so I could appreciate the nicer condos in the area where we eventually bought. Jay treated me as if I was buying a million-dollar property even though my price range was dramatically lower. He worked hard for his commission.

Bill S.

Kyle and Jay were selected because of the outstanding service they provided during the sale of our condo in 2007. Jay and Kyle Mitchell were not only trustworthy, but were extremely approachable and friendly. They understood and displayed the concern and magnitude of my personal family obligations to leave Florida and relocate to Maryland. My experience was rewarding and gratifying based on the overall reasons for selling the property.

Kia G.

My wife and I worked with Jay Mitchell when we recently purchased a condo on Siesta Key. Jay is incredibly responsive, hard-working, and attentive to detail. He was very forthcoming about the pros and cons of the various properties we considered. Above all, he is honest and trustworthy. We wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone who is buying or selling property, and we would use him and Kyle again in a heartbeat.

John K.

They were patient and encouraging and supportive. I feel they both went above and beyond to help sell this unit. I just wish to thank them for ALL they did to sell this property in a very difficult market, in what now has become a less than desirable neighborhood. I really have nothing but respect for how they handled everything, I would highly recommend them.

Linda G.

We found it very pleasant and helpful to work with Jay and Kyle. They were there with advice when we needed them. Jay was especially helpful after we moved out of town and repairs needed to be done. Jay stepped in and found a very efficient repair person and kept in close contact with us on the repairs. We would recommend Jay and Kyle to future sellers.

Ed & Gloria P.

We could not have a better team selling our home. Very hard-working team. Sold our home while we all have been dealing with the Corona virus. They were available to us 24/7. Very responsive to calls, emails, and lots of questions from us. Excellent marketing. Excellent team. If we have a need To sell or buy again, they are our go-to team."

Maria H.

My friend was so completely satisfied with Jay and Kyle, I decided to interview them and they are so knowledgeable and pleasant that there was no doubt they were the ones for me. My friend was right they are the best. I am completely satisfied with them and the sale of my home. What more can I say? They were perfect.

Timmie H.

Amazing! House was under contract before the first open house was scheduled. Everything was handled well. The photography, internet presentation, and flyers were excellent. Communication was very good.


Jay and Kyle were great to work with. They are very knowledgeable about the market and were very effective in getting my place sold. So very pleasant and friendly. I highly recommend them!


We have been dealing with Jay and Kyle for several years and have developed what I would call a personal relationship primarily based on their competence, trust, and sincerity.

John A.

Work With Us

Often, buyers don't visualize living in your home the way you do. We can make your home attractive to its ideal audience which can help you get top dollar.

Contact Us